The perception of Ibn Taimiyyah as being entirely opposed to Sufism has long been a subject of debate among scholars and historians. While he is often portrayed as a fierce critic of Sufism, new research by an orientalist and several trustworthy Sunni scholars suggests otherwise. This research sheds light on a different aspect of Ibn Taimiyyah—one that not only acknowledges his defense of Sufism but also suggests that he himself was well-versed in (sunnatic) Sufism, lived an ascetic life, and even wrote extensively on the discipline. This article explores the findings that challenge the commonly held narrative about Ibn Taimiyyah and his relationship with Sufism.
Ibn Taimiyyah’s Defense of Sufism
Despite his criticism of some Sufi practices, Ibn Taimiyyah recognized Sufism as an essential part of Islam when practiced in accordance with the Sunnah. In his various writings, he praised early Sufi masters such as Al-Junayd and Abdul Qadir Jilani, distinguishing between authentic Sufism and the excesses that had crept into the tradition over time. Ibn Taimiyyah's critique was primarily aimed at innovations (bid'ah) and deviations from the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), rather than Sufism itself as a spiritual discipline.
In his works, Ibn Taimiyyah often referred to the importance of purification of the soul (tazkiyyah) and spiritual excellence (ihsan), concepts that form the foundation of Sufism. He acknowledged the value of dhikr (remembrance of Allah), muraqabah (spiritual vigilance), and other aspects of traditional Sufi practice that align with the Qur'an and Sunnah. His opposition was directed at practices that deviated from these principles, such as excessive veneration of saints, seeking intercession through the deceased, and some esoteric interpretations of Islam that lacked scriptural backing.
The Ascetic Life of Ibn Taimiyyah
One of the key arguments supporting Ibn Taimiyyah’s affinity with Sufism is his ascetic lifestyle. He lived a life of simplicity, rejecting material comforts, and dedicating himself to worship, scholarship, and teaching. His commitment to self-discipline and his rejection of worldly pleasures align closely with the Sufi ideal of zuhd (detachment from worldly desires). He spent much of his life in prison due to his firm stance against political and theological corruption, further highlighting his commitment to truth over personal gain.
This austere lifestyle is in stark contrast to many contemporary Sufi figures who, as critics argue, have become immersed in materialism, fame, and the pursuit of worldly status. Ibn Taimiyyah’s life serves as a powerful example of true Sufism, which emphasizes spiritual refinement and sincerity over external displays of mysticism.
Writings on Sufism and Spiritual Purification
Contrary to popular belief, Ibn Taimiyyah wrote extensively on Sufism and spiritual purification. His works include discussions on the necessity of sincerity (ikhlas), reliance on Allah (tawakkul), and spiritual struggle (mujahadah). These themes are central to classical Sufi teachings, reinforcing the argument that he was not opposed to Sufism itself but rather to its corruptions.
One of his significant contributions is his commentary on Abdul Qadir Jilani’s works, where he elaborates on the necessity of adhering to the Qur'an and Sunnah in Sufi practices. Ibn Taimiyyah held Jilani in high regard, considering him one of the most exemplary figures in Islamic spirituality. Additionally, his discussions on al-Junayd’s teachings demonstrate a nuanced understanding of Sufism that goes beyond mere polemics.
Recognition by Ash‘ari Sufi Scholars
Prominent Ash‘ari Sufi scholars such as Nuh Ha Mim Keller have acknowledged Ibn Taimiyyah’s engagement with Sufism and his defense of its foundational principles. Keller, in particular, has pointed out that Ibn Taimiyyah’s critique was directed at misuses of Sufism rather than the discipline itself. Such recognition from scholars outside the Salafi tradition further supports the notion that Ibn Taimiyyah was not an outright opponent of Sufism but rather an advocate for its purification and reform.
A True Salafi and a True Sufi?
Ibn Taimiyyah’s unique position in Islamic scholarship allows him to be viewed as both a Salafi and a Sufi in the truest sense. His adherence to the creed of the Salaf (pious predecessors) and his rigorous commitment to the Qur'an and Sunnah align with the Salafi methodology. At the same time, his deep engagement with spiritual purification, his recognition of early Sufi figures, and his ascetic lifestyle align with the core values of true Sufism.
The concept of tasfiyyah (purification of Islamic teachings) and tarbiyyah (spiritual upbringing), terms later emphasized by scholars such as Muhammad Nasiruddin al-Albani, reflect Ibn Taimiyyah’s dual role as a reformer of both theology and spirituality. His vision was not to eradicate Sufism but to restore it to its original purity, free from innovations and distortions.
Conclusion
The conventional portrayal of Ibn Taimiyyah as wholly anti-Sufi is increasingly being challenged by new research and scholarly analysis. He emerges as a complex figure who upheld both the intellectual rigor of Salafism and the spiritual depth of Sufism. His writings, lifestyle, and defense of classical Sufi masters reveal that he saw true Sufism as an integral part of Islam. In a time when Sufism has, in some cases, been distorted by materialism and excess, Ibn Taimiyyah’s example stands as a powerful reminder of what genuine Islamic spirituality entails.
Thus, far from being a mere opponent of Sufism, Ibn Taimiyyah may well be regarded as one of its most sincere reformers—embodying both the scholarly depth of a true Salafi and the spiritual integrity of a true Sufi.
We invite visitors to research:Ibn Taymiyah
GEORGE MAKDISI
The Place of Tasawwuf in Traditional Islam
Nuh Ha Mim Keller on the sufism of Ibn Taimiyyah
The Debate with Ibn Taymiyya
The Testimony of Ibn Taymiyya to Ibn `Ata' Allah: Shaykh Ibn Taymiyya had been imprisoned in Alexandria. When the Sultan pardoned him, he came back to Cairo. At the time of the evening prayer he went to al-Azhar mosque where salat al-maghrib was being led by Shaykh Ahmad Ibn `Ata Allah al-Iskandari. Following the prayer, Ibn `Ata' Allah was surprised to discover that Ibn Taymiyya had been praying behind him
ON TASAWWUF
Shaykh Yusuf al-Qaradawi
Sufi quotations of Ibn Taimiyyah
Amazing words
Pandangan Ibn Taymiyyah Dalam Tasawuf
Hafiz Firdaus Abdullah
No comments:
Post a Comment